What each means
Tear-off removes the existing roof down to the deck. Recover installs new insulation or cover board and a new membrane over the existing roof.
What codes say
The International Building Code and International Residential Code limit recovering. In general, a new roof covering can't be installed over an existing roof that is water-soaked or deteriorated, or where there are already two or more applications of roof covering. Local amendments apply; your building department has the final word.
Costs
Tear-off and disposal typically add about $1–$2 per sq ft (HomeGuide). A recover avoids that and the disruption, but may require gravel removal, cover boards and careful attachment.

How to decide
- Moisture survey first: wet areas must come out either way.
- Count existing layers with a core cut.
- Check deck condition and attachment requirements.
- Consider the extra weight and edge height of a recover.


